| Ročník | Brankář | Obránce | Obránce | Útočník | Útočník | Útočník |
| 1982/1983 | Pelle Lindbergh
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Scott Stevens
(Washington Capitals) | Phil Housley
(Buffalo Sabres) | Dan Daoust
(Montreal Canadiens
Toronto Maple Leafs) | Steve Larmer
(Chicago Blackhawks) | Mats Näslund
(Montreal Canadiens) |
| 1983/1984 | Tom Barrasso
(Buffalo Sabres) | Thomas Eriksson
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Jamie Macoun
(Calgary Flames) | Steve Yzerman
(Detroit Red Wings) | Håkan Loob
(Calgary Flames) | Sylvain Turgeon
(Hartford Whalers) |
| 1984/1985 | Steve Penney
(Montreal Canadiens) | Chris Chelios
(Montreal Canadiens) | Bruce Bell
(Quebec Nordiques) | Mario Lemieux
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Tomas Sandström
(New York Rangers) | Warren Young
(Pittsburgh Penguins) |
| 1985/1986 | Patrick Roy
(Montreal Canadiens) | Gary Suter
(Calgary Flames) | Dana Murzyn
(Hartford Whalers) | Mike Ridley
(New York Rangers) | Kjell Dahlin
(Montreal Canadiens) | Wendel Clark
(Toronto Maple Leafs) |
| 1986/1987 | Ron Hextall
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Steve Duchesne
(Los Angeles Kings) | Brian Benning
(St. Louis Blues) | Jimmy Carson
(Los Angeles Kings) | Jim Sandlak
(Vancouver Canucks) | Luc Robitaille
(Los Angeles Kings) |
| 1987/1988 | Daren Pang
(Chicago Blackhawks) | Glen Wesley
(Boston Bruins) | Calle Johansson
(Buffalo Sabres) | Joe Nieuwendyk
(Calgary Flames) | Ray Sheppard
(Buffalo Sabres) | Iain Duncan
(Winnipeg Jets (1972–1996)) |
| 1988/1989 | Peter Sidorkiewicz
(Hartford Whalers) | Brian Leetch
(New York Rangers) | Zarley Zalapski
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Trevor Linden
(Vancouver Canucks) | Tony Granato
(New York Rangers) | David Volek
(New York Islanders) |
| 1989/1990 | Bob Essensa
(Winnipeg Jets (1972–1996)) | Brad Shaw
(Hartford Whalers) | Geoff Smith
(Edmonton Oilers) | Mike Modano
(Minnesota North Stars) | Sergej Makarov
(Calgary Flames) | Rod Brind'Amour
(St. Louis Blues) |
| 1990/1991 | Ed Belfour
(Chicago Blackhawks) | Eric Weinrich
(New Jersey Devils) | Rob Blake
(Los Angeles Kings) | Sergej Fjodorov
(Detroit Red Wings) | Ken Hodge
(Boston Bruins) | Jaromír Jágr
(Pittsburgh Penguins) |
| 1991/1992 | Dominik Hašek
(Chicago Blackhawks) | Nicklas Lidström
(Detroit Red Wings) | Vladimir Konstantinov
(Detroit Red Wings) | Kevin Todd
(New Jersey Devils) | Tony Amonte
(New York Rangers) | Gilbert Dionne
(Montreal Canadiens) |
| 1992/1993 | Felix Potvin
(Toronto Maple Leafs) | Scott Niedermayer
(New Jersey Devils) | Vladimir Malachov
(New York Islanders) | Eric Lindros
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Teemu Selänne
(Winnipeg Jets (1972–1996)) | Joe Juneau
(Boston Bruins) |
| 1993/1994 | Martin Brodeur
(New Jersey Devils) | Chris Pronger
(Hartford Whalers) | Boris Mironov
(Winnipeg Jets (1972–1996)/Edmonton Oilers) | Jason Arnott
(Edmonton Oilers) | Mikael Renberg
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Oleg Petrov
(Montreal Canadiens) |
| 1994/1995 | Jim Carey
(Washington Capitals) | Kenny Jönsson
(Toronto Maple Leafs) | Chris Therien
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Peter Forsberg
(Quebec Nordiques) | Jeff Friesen
(San Jose Sharks) | Paul Kariya
(Anaheim Ducks) |
| 1995/1996 | Corey Hirsch
(Vancouver Canucks) | Ed Jovanovski
(Florida Panthers) | Kyle McLaren
(Boston Bruins) | Daniel Alfredsson
(Ottawa Senators) | Éric Dazé
(Chicago Blackhawks) | Petr Sýkora
(New Jersey Devils) |
| 1996/1997 | Patrick Lalime
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Bryan Berard
(New York Islanders) | Janne Niinimaa
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Sergej Berezin
(Toronto Maple Leafs) | Jim Campbell
(St. Louis Blues) | Jarome Iginla
(Calgary Flames) |
| 1997/1998 | Jamie Storr
(Los Angeles Kings) | Derek Morris
(Calgary Flames) | Mattias Öhlund
(Vancouver Canucks) | Patrik Eliáš
(New Jersey Devils) | Mike Johnson
(Toronto Maple Leafs) | Sergej Samsonov
(Boston Bruins) |
| 1998/1999 | Jamie Storr
(Los Angeles Kings) | Tom Poti
(Edmonton Oilers) | Sami Salo
(Ottawa Senators) | Chris Drury
(Colorado Avalanche) | Milan Hejduk
(Colorado Avalanche) | Marián Hossa
(Ottawa Senators) |
| 1999/2000 | Brian Boucher
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Brian Rafalski
(New Jersey Devils) | Brad Stuart
(San Jose Sharks) | Simon Gagne
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Scott Gomez
(New Jersey Devils) | Mike York
(New York Rangers) |
| 2000/2001 | Jevgenij Nabokov
(San Jose Sharks) | Ľubomír Višňovský
(Los Angeles Kings) | Colin White
(New Jersey Devils) | Martin Havlát
(Ottawa Senators) | Brad Richards
(Tampa Bay Lightning) | Shane Willis
(Carolina Hurricanes) |
| 2001/2002 | Dan Blackburn
(New York Rangers) | Nick Boynton
(Boston Bruins) | Rostislav Klesla
(Columbus Blue Jackets) | Dany Heatley
(Atlanta Thrashers) | Kristian Huselius
(Florida Panthers) | Ilja Kovalčuk
(Atlanta Thrashers) |
| 2002/2003 | Sebastien Caron
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Jay Bouwmeester
(Florida Panthers) | Barret Jackman
(St. Louis Blues) | Tyler Arnason
(Chicago Blackhawks) | Rick Nash
(Columbus Blue Jackets) | Henrik Zetterberg
(Detroit Red Wings) |
| 2003/2004 | Andrew Raycroft
(Boston Bruins) | John-Michael Liles
(Colorado Avalanche) | Joni Pitkänen
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Trent Hunter
(New York Islanders) | Ryan Malone
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Michael Ryder
(Montreal Canadiens) |
| 2004/2005 | Sezóna zrušena |
| 2005/2006 | Henrik Lundqvist
(New York Rangers) | Andrej Meszároš
(Ottawa Senators) | Dion Phaneuf
(Calgary Flames) | Brad Boyes
(Boston Bruins) | Sidney Crosby
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Alexandr Ovečkin
(Washington Capitals) |
| 2006/2007 | Mike Smith
(Dallas Stars) | Matt Carle
(San Jose Sharks) | Marc-Edouard Vlasic
(San Jose Sharks) | Jevgenij Malkin
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Jordan Staal
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Paul Stastny
(Colorado Avalanche) |
| 2007/2008 | Carey Price
(Montreal Canadiens) | Tobias Enström
(Atlanta Thrashers) | Tom Gilbert
(Edmonton Oilers) | Nicklas Bäckström
(Washington Capitals) | Patrick Kane
(Chicago Blackhawks) | Jonathan Toews
(Chicago Blackhawks) |
| 2008/2009 | Steve Mason
(Columbus Blue Jackets) | Drew Doughty
(Los Angeles Kings) | Luke Schenn
(Toronto Maple Leafs) | Patrik Berglund
(St. Louis Blues) | Bobby Ryan
(Anaheim Ducks) | Kris Versteeg
(Chicago Blackhawks) |
| 2009/2010 | Jimmy Howard
(Detroit Red Wings) | Michael Del Zotto
(New York Rangers) | Tyler Myers
(Buffalo Sabres) | Niclas Bergfors
(Atlanta Thrashers) | Matt Duchene
(Colorado Avalanche) | John Tavares
(New York Islanders) |
| 2010/2011 | Corey Crawford
(Chicago Blackhawks) | John Carlson
(Washington Capitals) | P. K. Subban
(Montreal Canadiens) | Logan Couture
(San Jose Sharks) | Michael Grabner
(New York Islanders) | Jeff Skinner
(Carolina Hurricanes) |
| 2011/2012 | Jhonas Enroth
(Buffalo Sabres) | Justin Faulk
(Carolina Hurricanes) | Jake Gardiner
(Toronto Maple Leafs) | Adam Henrique
(New Jersey Devils) | Gabriel Landeskog
(Colorado Avalanche) | Ryan Nugent-Hopkins
(Edmonton Oilers) |
| 2012/2013 | Jake Allen
(St. Louis Blues) | Jonas Brodin
(Minnesota Wild) | Justin Schultz
(Edmonton Oilers) | Brendan Gallagher
(Montreal Canadiens) | Jonathan Huberdeau
(Florida Panthers) | Brandon Saad
(Chicago Blackhawks) |
| 2013/2014 | Frederik Andersen
(Anaheim Ducks) | Torey Krug
(Boston Bruins) | Hampus Lindholm
(Anaheim Ducks) | Tyler Johnson
(Tampa Bay Lightning) | Nathan MacKinnon
(Colorado Avalanche) | Ondřej Palát
(Tampa Bay Lightning) |
| 2014/2015 | Jake Allen
(St. Louis Blues) | Aaron Ekblad
(Florida Panthers) | John Klingberg
(Dallas Stars) | Filip Forsberg
(Nashville Predators) | Johnny Gaudreau
(Calgary Flames) | Mark Stone
(Ottawa Senators) |
| 2015/2016 | John Gibson
(Anaheim Ducks) | Shayne Gostisbehere
(Philadelphia Flyers) | Colton Parayko
(St. Louis Blues) | Artěmij Panarin
(Chicago Blackhawks) | Connor McDavid
(Edmonton Oilers) | Jack Eichel
(Buffalo Sabres) |
| 2016/2017 | Matt Murray
(Pittsburgh Penguins) | Brady Skjei
(New York Rangers) | Zach Werenski
(Columbus Blue Jackets) | Patrik Laine
(Winnipeg Jets) | Mitchell Marner
(Toronto Maple Leafs) | Auston Matthews
(Toronto Maple Leafs) |
| 2017/2018 | Juuse Saros
(Nashville Predators) | Will Butcher
(New Jersey Devils) | Charlie McAvoy
(Boston Bruins) | Mathew Barzal
(New York Islanders) | Brock Boeser
(Vancouver Canucks) | Clayton Keller
(Arizona Coyotes) |
| 2018/2019 | Jordan Binnington
(St. Louis Blues) | Rasmus Dahlin
(Buffalo Sabres) | Miro Heiskanen
(Dallas Stars) | Anthony Cirelli
(Tampa Bay Lightning) | Elias Pettersson
(Vancouver Canucks) | Brady Tkachuk
(Ottawa Senators) |
| 2019/2020 | Elvis Merzlikins
(Columbus Blue Jackets) | Cale Makar
(Colorado Avalanche) | Quinn Hughes
(Vancouver Canucks) | Dominik Kubalík
(Chicago Blackhawks) | Victor Olofsson
(Buffalo Sabres) | Nick Suzuki
(Montreal Canadiens) |
| 2020/2021 | Alex Nedeljkovic
(Carolina Hurricanes) | K'Andre Miller
(New York Rangers) | Ty Smith
(New Jersey Devils) | Kirill Kaprizov
(Minnesota Wild) | Josh Norris
(Ottawa Senators) | Jason Robertson
(Dallas Stars) |
| 2021/2022 | Jeremy Swayman
(Boston Bruins) | Alexandre Carrier
(Nashville Predators) | Moritz Seider
(Detroit Red Wings) | Lucas Raymond
(Detroit Red Wings) | Michael Bunting
(Toronto Maple Leafs) | Trevor Zegras
(Anaheim Ducks) |
| 2022/2023 | Stuart Skinner
(Edmonton Oilers) | Owen Power
(Buffalo Sabres) | Jake Sanderson
(Ottawa Senators) | Matty Beniers
(Seattle Kraken) | Wyatt Johnston
(Dallas Stars) | Matias Maccelli
(Arizona Coyotes) |
| 2023/2024 | Pjotr Kočetkov
(Carolina Hurricanes) | Luke Hughes
(New Jersey Devils) | Brock Faber
(Minnesota Wild) | Marco Rossi
(Minnesota Wild) | Logan Cooley
(Arizona Coyotes) | Connor Bedard
(Chicago Blackhawks) |